Showing posts with label Frida Kahlo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Frida Kahlo. Show all posts

Monday, March 23, 2026

A deep dive into Frida Kahlo's The Two Fridas

A few days ago I heard a YouTube reviewer describe Frida Kahlo's The Two Fridas (1939) as Mexico's Mona Lisa. And that resonated with me for, like Mona Lisa, The Two Fridas is an iconic work created by an iconic artist which has attained the pinnacle of national cultural relativism. In a characteristic not shared by Mona Lisa, The Two Fridas is a homegrown product created by a national and resident in a national institution.

Frida Kahlo, The Two Fridas, 1939

Before delving into the painting I would like to spend a little time discussing Frida' views on her art and the immediate context within which the piece was created.

Frida married the famed muralist Diego Rivera in 1929. He was 20 years her senior and on his third marriage. During the 1930s, Frida underwent a number of surgical procedures to include an appendectomy, amputation of gangrenous toes, numerous foot-related surgeries, and two miscarriages. In addition, her mother died in 1932.

The union was "unconventional and problematic" with numerous affairs on both sides (including one with Diego and Frida's sister Cristina (pbs.org)). Diego's philandering exacerbated the lifelong pain resulting from her trolley accident. As she stated, "I suffered two great accidents in my life ... One in which a streetcar knocked me down ... The other accident is Diego." In one of her letters to Diego at the time doctors were considering amputating her leg, Frida stated "No, I was already a married woman when I lost you, again, for the umpteenth time maybe, and still I survived ... I am not afraid of pain and you know it. It is almost inherent to my being, although I confess that I suffered, and a great deal, when you cheated on me every time you did it, not just with my sister but with so many other women" (timesnownews.com).

Here we already begin to see themes of emotional and physical pain as endemic in Frida's life; Diego as the source of much of that emotional pain; and her ability to survive in the face of that pain.

In discussing her paintings, Frida stated thusly (The Life and Times of Frida Kahlo, pbs.org):
Really, I do not know whether my paintings are surrealist or not, but I do know they are the frankest expression of myself ... since my subjects have always been my sensations, my state of mind and the profound reactions that life has been producing in me, I have frequently objectified all this in figures of myself, which were the most sincere and real thing that I could do in order to express what I felt inside and outside of myself.
Here Frida stipulates that the subjects of her paintings are objectification of non-physical aspects of her life.

In 1938, just prior to her leaving Mexico for her first solo exhibition in New York, Diego informed Frida that he intended to divorce her. This was devastating news and another in a long list of betrayals on his part. In 1939, "anxious and adrift," Frida traveled from the US to France at the invitation of Breton who promised a surrealist-themed, Parisian exhibition of her work. In addition to all of the personal issues she was facing: her materials were stuck in customs for an extended period; her accommodations were less than desirable; she found the surrealist community insufferable; and the exhibition would not be of her works solely. Frida complained about all this in a series of letters to her lover, the American photographer Nickolas Murray. At the conclusion of her Parisian trip, Frida headed to New York where she was supposed to liaise with Murray but he waved her off as he had found a new love.

This was the Frida that returned to Mexico to face a divorce and all that a life outside the Diego orbit would entail.

The Painting
The Two Fridas is a double self-portrait which was completed in 1939, shortly after Frida and Diego's divorce.


The rightmost figure is an image of Frida dressed in a traditional Tehuana ensemble (paying homage to her indigenous heritage) looking directly at the viewer and with legs at a "mansplaining" angle. She is holding a miniature portrait of Diego as a child between her thumb and forefinger, said portrait linked to an extra-body heart by a blood-vessel-adjacent structure.

Detail from The Two Fridas
(Source: smarthistory.org)

Frida's seating position seems non-natural in relation to the bench.

The leftmost Frida is dressed in a high-necked, European-style wedding dress (paying homage to her father's European roots) and her facial pallor is whiter than is the case for "Traditional" Frida. The "hearts" of both Fridas are connected by a single circuit but Euro-Frida's heart exhibits evidence of severe damage. There is an unregulated branching  of the Euro-Frida vessel with the pre-heart branch reaching downwards and spilling fluid onto the floral-patterned skirt even though restrained by a pincer which has been deployed to staunch the flow.

The two Fridas are holding hands and both possess the unmistakeable features of the creator: bold eyebrows; facial hair; austere outward gazes; and banded updos. The angle of the bench visible to the left of Euro-Frida does not comport with the angle visible between the two forms.

The barren landscape is of a reddish-brown hue and stretches to the horizon where it gives way to storm-cloud-laden skies. 

Initially Frida wrote in her diary that this painting originated from her memory of an imaginary childhood friend but later admitted that it expressed her desperation and loneliness with the separation from Diego. "The divorce period is often described as emotionally intense for Kahlo, and it aligns with a time when her work carried a sharp sense of rupture and self-examination. Divorce, for her, wasn't just a legal change. It was a confrontation with who she was outside the relationship and whether such a change was even possible after years of being intertwined with Rivera's world" (estragy.com).

In an insight shared with a friend, Frida indicated that Traditional Frida represented the Frida that Diego loved while Euro-Frida represented the Frida that he rejected.

Frida generally worked on smaller canvasses. At 5.69 feet x 5.68 feet, The Two Fridas marked a dramatic departure from her norm. The painting was acquired by the National Institute of Fine Arts in Mexico City at a cost of 4000 pesos (about $1000) including 36 pesos for the frame (This was the most money she had received for a painting during her lifetime.). It was included in the International Exhibition of Surrealism at the Gallery of Mexican Art (Mexico City) in 1940 and was transferred to the Museum of Modern Art (Mexico City) in 1966.

My Interpretation

The system illustrated herein is not a closed-loop system. It begins with an immature, childlike Diego being the fount of emotion-battering material which Traditional Frida, even though being closest to the source, is able to impassively process and filter before passing it on. Frida has referred to Diego as being an accident and has referred to him in other sources as a child. She expects pain from this source and the figure indicates that it is the Mexican side of the coin that is able to handle this pain impassively and move on. Hence, this is the Frida that Diego likes. This is the Frida that allows him to be indisciplined and that continues to absorb the blows without holding up a mirror to his face.

The caustic emotional brew does its damage to Euro-Frida, whose seat of emotions is visibly scarred; even though some of the mess has been directed to the off -channel. Euro-Frida is unable to internalize the material and some of it spills out into the open, sullying reputations in the process. Diego does not like this Frida. By his standards, she is weak. She refuses to (or can't) suffer silently. Her pallor and the stuff that slips out between the pincer's grip alerts the external world to the pain and suffering that the system is being subjected to.

Tuesday, July 8, 2025

A Framework for viewing the works of Frida Kahlo

I have visited a number of Frida Kahlo exhibits over the years: Virginia Museum of Fine Arts (Frida: Beyond the Myth), Frist Art Museum (Mexican Modernism), Brooklyn Museum (Frida Kahlo: Appearances can be Deceiving); Museum of Fine Arts Houston (Frida: The Making of an Icon); MOMA (Collection); and National Museum of Women in the Arts (Collection). 

Kahlo exhibitions sourced (clockwise from top left):
Frist, Brooklyn Museum, Virginia MFA, and
MFA Houston

The largest of the Kahlo exhibitions I have viewed was the one at the Brooklyn Museum; unfortunately, no photography was allowed. The most recent exhibition viewed -- Museum Fine Arts Houston -- restricted photography around a subset of the artist's work but all others were fair game. The Virginia Museum exhibition was the most fruitful in that it was rich in Frida's works and also provided the "backbone" for the framework.

I was able to use this backbone to develop trees of the artist's work by period, using images captured during visits to said exhibitions. Those trees are displayed below.

It is impossible to separate the Frida Kahlo story from Frida Kahlo's art. Caravaggio led a fairly tempestuous life, and painted between bouts of "criming," but his experiences were not reflected in his art. Art was on one plane and his lived experience on another. Not so Frida. Her experiences framed her art, serving as source material and impacting how she produced her works.

Frida Kahlo had an intimate relationship with pain throughout her life; and many of her paintings reported on this pain or reflected on its effects. Frida had polio at an early age, resulting in one leg being shorter than the other. She had a catastrophic accident when she was 18 and suffered chronic, debilitating pain for the rest of her life. She married Diego Rivera in 1929 and suffered through multiple episodes of his unfaithfulness, including with her sister. Frida suffered a miscarriage, probably a result of internal damage suffered during the accident.

Frida's paintings are raw and emotion-filled but they are also steeped in Mexicanidad, a key ingredient of Mexican Modernism. Mexican Modernism arose as a result of the post-revolution Mexican regime seeking to use culture as a means to unite the nation and visual artists efforts to use their craft in furtherance of this goal. The chart below graphically illustrates the road to this new Mexican art school.


"Frida Kahlo's art is a tapestry of symbolism, weaving together themes of physical pain (The Broken Column), emotional suffering (Memory, the Heart), and cultural identity (Self-Portrait with Thorn Necklace and Hummingbird) ... Her use of vibrant color, traditional, attire, and native flora and fauna reaffirm her cultural roots."

Frida Kahlo, The Broken Column, 1944
(Source: fridakahlo.org)



Kahlo's paintings often adopt a surreal quality (The Two Fridas) while gender and identity also surface as central themes (Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair).

Frida Kahlo, The Two Fridas, 1939
(Source: wikipedia.org)


The Surrealist establishment sought to claim Frida as their own but she was resistant. André Breton, one of the leading lights of the movement, visited Mexico in 1938 and described her work as a "ribbon wrapped around a bomb." He invited her to exhibit in Paris, which she eventually did, but the scene was not convincing to her. She resisted the Surrealist categorization famously stating "I never painted dreams. I painted my own reality."

Frida had first taken up painting during her recovery from the accident and had spent many a day in the courtyard garden of the family home (now called La Casa Azul) in Coyocán, a Mexico City borough. "The courtyard garden became her sanctuary and an important source of artistic inspiration. She embraced representations of foliage, fruit, and flowers, often using them to represent fertility and to celebrate the natural beauty of Mexico."

Below are the period trees of which I spoke earlier, wherein Frida's works are distributed between six periods, beginning with her early life and ending with her death in 1954. The dates and storyboards that form the trunks of these trees are photographs of the Frida Kahlo Timeline presented at the exhibition.


Frida's first painting in this collection was done in 1925. It is markedly different from anything else in this or any other period. The earth tones and focus on structures was not vintage Frida. Her skill as a portrait painter is evident even in this early stage with Self-Portrait in a Velvet Dress giving off a Mannerist whiff.


Frida married Diego in 1929 and they traveled to San Francisco in 1930 for him to fulfill some mural commissions. Frida exhibited some of her work for the first time in 1931 and, in the same year, completed the two works shown above.


This period shows a greater number of drawings than any of the other periods. This may be a function of the data that I have access to rather than an actual fact. It will become clearer as I build my data base up with future sightings. The couple were in Detroit and then New York during this time.


This was a period of marital turmoil capped by Diego's affair with Frida's sister.The couple separated but reconciled upon Frida's return from New York. The turmoil seemed to energize Frida. This was her most productive period to date. Her heart was broken, captured in The Heart (1937) and Survivor (1938). She began her embrace of cultural attire as shown in the two self-portraits in the top left.

I saw Fulani-Chang and I (1939) during a November 2025 visit to New York’s Museum of Modern Art. The current manifestation is in two parts with an oil-on-board painting on the left and a mirror in a painted frame on the right. The mirror -- added to the original (1937) composition after 1939 -- was a tool she "often used to extend her field of vision while painting."


The portraits in the 1940+ period begin to show the growing strain on Frida's face. This period also evidences a greater incidence of surrealist-adjacent works. She remarries Diego and affirms their bond by painting him onto her forehead in a few of the works. This was another very productive period.

I also saw Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair (1940) during that November 2025 visit to New York’s Museum of Modern Art. Kerry Downey describes the painting thusly:
She’s wearing this oversized gray suit and crimson shirt. That’s a reference to Diego Rivera, the Mexican mural painter. She was married to him, but then they divorced a few months before she made this painting. If you look up at the top, you can see words and musical notes she included from a popular Mexican folk song. It’s about a man who loved a woman for her hair. But now that she’s cut it off, he doesn’t love her anymore.

The final period of her life showed a number of still lifes and bright red colors; and these paintings seem to almost jump out of the canvas. The remaining works include one of her most surrealist efforts, The Love Embrace of the Universe.

Some observations:

  • A significant percentage of the paintings are portraits
  • There are many more drawings in the early portion of her career than later
  • There is great consistency in depiction of her facial features in the portraits
  • The first still life observed was Magnolias in 1945. She followed with a number of substantive works in that genre in later years
  • The 1930s and 40s were her most productive years
  • Surrealists wanted to claim her as their own and The Love Embrace of the Universe ..., provides ample evidence as to why.
This is by no means the totality of Frida's works. As I come into contact with more of her paintings, I will update the trees accordingly.



Tuesday, June 4, 2019

Frida Kahlo, Diego Rivera, and Mexican Modernism at the Frist Art Museum

I visited the Brooklyn Museum exhibition Frida Kahlo: Appearances Can Be Deceiving earlier this year and became an even greater fan of the artist's work as a result. A recent visit to the Frist Museum (Nashville, TN) provided visibility into Kahlo works that I had not seen previously but also allowed me to see the artist within the context of the Mexican Modernism School and the artists plying their trade therein. The Frist exhibition is titled Frida Kahlo, Diego Rivera, and Mexican Modernism and is drawn from the Jacques and Natasha Gelman Collection of Modern Mexican art. The exhibition runs through September 2nd.

The Love Embrace of the Universe, the Earth
(Mexico), Diego, Me, and Senor Xolotl, 1949
Frida Kahlo



Mexican Modernism arose as a result of the post-revolution Mexican regime seeking to use culture as a means to unite the nation and visual artists efforts to use their craft in furtherance of this goal. The chart below graphically illustrates the road to this new Mexican art school.
The Jacques and Natasha Gelman collection is one of the most extensive collections of Mexican Modernist art in the world. Jacques and Natasha Gelman were both born in Eastern Europe but met and married in Mexico City. After the outbreak of the World War II, they made Mexico their home.

They began collecting art soon after their marriage, commissioning and buying works from the leading Mexican artists. They became friendly with most of the artists, acting sometimes as patrons and other times as promoters. Jacques died in 1986 and Natasha 12 years later. Natasha had continued adding to the collection after Jacques' death and the collection continues to be expanded post her death.

The stars of the exhibition are the husband and wife team Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo.
Rivera's bombastic personality, revolutionary politics, and inspiring murals made him a celebrity. Although at one time he overshadowed his equally talented wife, Kahlo's fame has far outstripped Rivera's since his death. The raw emotion of her paintings still resonates today, and her intense self-portraits have made her face familiar throughout the globe.
In addition to works from these two personalities, the exhibition includes paintings from Lola Álvarez Bravo, María Izquerdo, David Alfano Sisqueiros, Rufino Tamayo, and others. The exhibition also includes a large number of photographs and garments and jewelry akin to those worn by Frida during her time in the limelight.

While murals are a key part of the Mexican Modernism movement, only one example of this genre is included in the exhibition and that is a reproduction of Diego Rivera's The History of Mexico. Diego began painting this mural in 1929, the year he married Frida. This mural is emplaced in the main stairway of the National Palace in Mexico City and cemented Rivera's place as the foremost Mexican muralist. The mural chronicles the history of the country with the Aztec culture at the base. The topmost layer depicts the country's future.

The History of Mexico (detail)
Diego Rivera, 1929 - 1935

The remaining Diego Rivera works in the exhibition combine to show the range of his talent beyond murals. From a blending of the human and botanical (Landscape with Cacti, 1931), to portraiture (Portrait of Cristina Kahlo, 1934), to nude studies (Nude with Long Hair (Dolores Olmedo), 1930; Nude with Beads (Frida Kahlo), 1930), to Cubism (The Last Hour, 1915), to genre (The Healer, 1943), Diego's range is phenomenal and his work captivating. The most stunning of his efforts in the exhibition though were Portrait of Natasha Gelman, Sunflowers, and Calla Lily Vendor.

In 1943, Jacques Gelman commissioned Diego Rivera to paint a portrait of his wife; the below work was the result.

Portrait of Natasha Gelman, 1943
Diego Rivera

The portrait lies along a perfect diagonal line with the subject framed at the head by upright Calla Lilies and the litheness of the lower extremities accentuated by horizontal lilies.The shape of the gown aligns with the shape of the lilies. The red hair and bold stare of the sitter contrasts with the other major elements of the picture.

The Calla Lilies in this picture meshes nicely with the mass of lilies in the Calla Lily Vendor and they contrast, both in color and subject, with Sunflowers which, in this exhibition, is positioned between the two.

Sunflowers, 1943
Diego Rivera

Calla Lily Vendor, 1943
Diego Rivera

Frida Kahlo had an intimate relationship with pain throughout her life; and many of her paintings reported on this pain or reflected on its effects. Frida had polio at an early age, resulting in one leg being shorter than the other. She had a catastrophic accident when she was 18 and suffered chronic, debilitating pain for the rest of her life. She married Diego Rivera in 1929 and suffered through multiple episodes of his unfaithfulness, including with her sister. Frida suffered a miscarriage, probably a result of internal damage suffered during the accident when she was 18 years old,

Frida's paintings are raw and emotion-filled but they are also steeped in Mexicanidad, a key ingredient of Mexican Modernism.

Diego on my Mind (Self-Portrait as Tehuana), 1943
Frida Kahlo

Self-Portrait with Necklace, 1933
Frida Kahlo

Self-Portrait on Bed, 1937
Frida Kahlo

Self-Portrait with Red and Gold Dress, 1941
Frida Kahlo

Frida and the Miscarriage, 1932
Frida Kahlo

The third leg of Mexican Modernism was photography and that mode is well represented in this exhibition. Photographs (black and white) serve as separators for the main segments of the exhibition. For example, there are a set of pictures between the first works and the Diego Rivera paintings and another set of photographs between the diego and the Frida works. The pictures between the Frida and Kahlo paintings are pictures featuring the husband and wife in various settings and poses.



I have been studying the work of Frida Kahlo intensively over the course of the past year and this exhibition allowed me to add to that knowledge base. But it also framed her work within this broader school and given me a path for further investigation.

©EverythingElse238

Sunday, March 3, 2019

Frida Kahlo linkages in the National Portrait Gallery's Eye to I exhibition

Frida Kahlo, the Mexican artist currently featured in the Brooklyn Museum's Frida Kahlo: Appearances can be Deceiving exhibit, is linked to a number of the artists included in the National Portrait Gallery's (NPGs) exhibition titled Eye to I: Self-Portraits from 1900 to Today. Drawing from the museum's sizable collection of self-portraits, this exhibit "seeks to reassess the significance of self-portraiture in relation to the country's history and culture."

A Frida Kahlo self-portrait was not included in the NPG exhibit but I was able to locate the one below in the collection of the National Museum of Women in the Arts (NMWA).

Frida Kahlo
Self-Portrait Dedicated to Leon Trotsky, 1937
Oil on Masonite

The Kahlo self-portrait commemorates the brief affair that she had with Leo Trotsky shortly after his arrival in Mexico in 1937 as well as stipulating her political leanings. The letter in her hand is a dedication to Trotsky which states "with all my love." Kahlo is wearing the distinctive clothing of the Tehuantepec women of southwest Mexico while the staging of the photo draws upon a Mexican vernacular style called retablos.

The Eye to I self-portrait with the most direct link to Kahlo is that of her husband Diego Rivera. The two were first married in 1929. "Theirs was a volatile relationship that underwent marital infidelities, the pressure of Rivera's career, a divorce and remarriage, and Kahlo's deteriorating health" (NMNA).

Diego Rivera
1930
Lithograph

Diego is remembered for his public art and murals in Mexico and the US, probably the most famous of which is the 27-panel fresco Detroit Industry prepared for the Detroit Institute of Arts. According to the notes accompanying the exhibit, "The lively crosshatching strokes used to model the contours of his face relate directly to the technique he employed in his monumental murals."

Nickolas Muray emigrated to the US from his native Hungary in 1913 and by 1920, he was a much-sought-after photographer to the stars. He met Frida Kahlo in 1931 and they became lovers, a relationship which lasted for a decade.

Nickolas Muray
c. 1935
Gelatin silver print

During the Depression years the celebrity business dried up so Muray switched to commercial and advertising work, becoming a color-photography expert in the process. He is shown above with his one-shot color-separation camera.

Louise Nevelson was a sculptor and artist who briefly apprenticed with Diego Rivera, Frida Kahlo's husband. According to the notes, "... wiry scratches, squiggles, bold black contours, and a red overdrawing compete for attention. The robust features convey her driven personality along with the muscular expression evident in her later sculpture. The double red contours of the face hint at both profile and full-face poses, suggestive of a rotating head, Pablo Picasso's cubism, and multiple-exposure photography.


Louise Nevelson
c. 1938
Ink and watercolor on paper

Pele deLappe met Diego Rivera and, as a result, became a sketching companion of Frida. She studied in New York in the early 1930s but moved back to San Francisco in 1934. Her works reflected the influences of Rivera and another of his friends David Alfara Siqueiros. "Her lithographs of the 1930s had a muralist's sensibility, with simplified compositions, broad planes, low viewpoints, and heroic figural forms."

Pele deLappe
1938
Graphite on paper

The above drawing conveys her beauty and self-assurance framed in the affect of a mural's monumentality.

©Everythingelse238

In the Footsteps of Piero della Francesca: Queen of Sheba, King Solomon, and Burial of the Wood

Just below the Death of Adam in Basilica di San Francesca's Bacci Chapel is the two-scene fresco Procession of the Queen of Sheba and M...