Showing posts with label Book review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book review. Show all posts

Friday, October 15, 2021

Book Review: The Love Songs of W. E. B. DuBois by Honoreé Fannone Jeffers

Honoreé Fannone Jeffers' The Love Songs of W. E. B. DuBois is a literary tour de force. 

The book has a significant historic-fiction component, as the early threads of the family tree began pulling themselves together in the "place between the tall trees" -- the place that would come to be called Chicasetta in the state that would come to be called Georgia. Land stolen from the Creek Nation by treaty, and then by force, and worked by Black slaves brought from across the Atlantic and, when that trade was banned, from other slave states, or brought back (escapees or otherwise) from the Northern states.

And these disparate threads would culminate in the three children of Maybelle Lee as laid out by the author in the very early phases of the book. But it was information provided too early to be anything but confusing; so we moved along.

But this book is more than historical fiction. The second thread contained within the covers is a coming-of-age/coming-to-grips/fictional memoir/self-realization/finding-her-roots story centered around Ailey, the final addition to the family tree and the youngest of three daughters of a "light-skinned" black doctor and his "darker-skinned", stay-at-home wife. This family lived in an urban setting but, given their roots, the mother and daughters returned to Chicasetta annually for summer holidays. This thread revolves around family secrets, childhood sexual abuse, "it takes a village" to raise a black child, meeting family expectations, finding something you actually love doing, and genealogical detective work.

There is a third thread here which, even though encapsulated in the Ailey story, sticks out for me, having, as it does, a cultural anthropology bent. It is the story of education and scholarship in forward-leaning black households/communities. It began early in this book with the discussion of school choices for Ailey in her Elementary and High School years and continued into her choice of college. And the pressure here was applied by parents and relatives who saw Ailey as being Doctor material and, in order to realize their goal, she had to attend certain schools. The anthropological nature of this space is further highlighted by the author's coverage of black college culture (with the sororities and the fraternities). The thread continues through to the academic side once Ailey becomes a researcher and begins her interaction with folks on that side of the college coin.

This is a multi-faceted effort, to say the least. The lift becomes heavier in that the material is not presented in a continuous fashion. Rather, the multiple threads of the historic fiction is interspersed with multiple threads of the Ailey stories at random times and in randomly sized chunks.

Further complexing the initiative is the author's "pass the mic" approach to perspective. It is brilliant in that it fleshes out the stories fully and reveals the wizardry of the author in that she dons the mantle and convincingly tells the stories of different races, ethnicities, and age groups in different temporal intervals. Even trickier, she tells some stories of the same person at different stages in their development. In that the reader becomes accustomed to this construct, the book suffers when it is not utilized. For example, the historical family members who went off to Boston lost their voices, with their stories eventually excavated by Ailey and clarified by her Uncle (Root). But it did not have the same vibrancy and depth. In wine terms, it was not persistent.

This is an ambitious, female-centered, narrative from a story teller who is comfortable spinning complex yarns. But I am even more impressed by the breadth and depth of her research and her ability to exploit same to build robust literary structures within which her characters are seamlessly deployed. The author delves into topics as far afield as black incorporation into indigenous tribes (a topic with some currency), slavery in the south, the slave trade (both across the Atlantic and intra-US, the abuse of slave bodies by master and overseer alike, the dehumanizing sexual trauma experienced by black female slaves and the resulting further male emasculation, sharecropping, and more currently, country life, colorism, life for young black college students, and black scholarship. And the author does not just place the characters into historical settings; rather, she weaves them into the fabric of their times.

This is the initial fiction effort by the accomplished poet and essayist Honoreé Fannone Jeffers and it is immense in scope and size; 797 pages to be exact. In her NPR interview, Ms. Jeffers indicated that she had the book sold at 400 pages but took another almost 400 pages and 2+ years to complete the effort. This book is worth your time. Pay special attention to the Acknowledgments and Archival Coda at the back of the book -- they are informative in their own right as to the genesis and research directions pursued. Take notes as you read book, especially when new characters are introduced. It will prove helpful, especially if you have to lay the book aside for a while.

©EverythingElse238

Thursday, August 8, 2019

Book Review: Tony Horwitz's Spying on the South

I heard Tony Horwitz interviewed by Mary Corrigan on NPRs Fresh Air earlier this year regarding his book Spying on the South. I was intrigued by the author and the story behind the book so I purchased a copy. You can imagine my shock when driving home about a week later I heard it announced on the radio that Horwitz had collapsed and died of a heart attack while in Washington DC on a book-promotion tour.


Horwitz was a Pulitzer-Prize-winning "... journalist, historian and author whose books have graced best-seller lists and college syllabuses." His books included One for the Road, A Voyage Long and Strange, and the acclaimed travelogue Confederates in the Attic.

In this, his final book, Horwitz describes retracing a portion of Fredrick Law Olmstead's journeys through the South between the years 1852 and 1854. Olmstead is best known as the landscape architect of Central Park, the US Capitol Grounds, Biltmore Estate, and many college campuses and residential neighborhoods across the country. Prior to his trips across the south, Olmstead's distant past included stints as a merchant seaman, an experimental farmer, and a European traveler.

Frederick Law Olmstead

Over the course of his travel through the South, Olmstead served as an undercover correspondent known as Yeoman, "a Connecticut Yankee exploring the Cotton Kingdom on the eve of secession and the Civil war." Olmstead was 30 years old when he undertook this assignment, --"restless on his farm" and "romantically adrift" -- and he hoped that a short sojourn in the South would both renew him and provide an avenue for success as a writer. Instead he made two major journeys to the area, resulting in numerous newspaper dispatches and three books about the South.

Prior to embarking on his journeys, Olmstead had held the belief that the residents of the South would be susceptible to reasoned discourse; by the end of his travels, he had been disabused of that notion. He found the South's leading men to be:
  • Implacable
  • Convinced of the superiority of their caste-bound society
  • Intent on expanding it
  • Utterly contemptuous of the North.
Writing about these leading men seven years before the Civil War, Olmstead described them as "a mischievous class."

In 1953 Olmstead's three books were abridged into a single volume called The Cotton Kingdom, a volume which Horwitz had used in a 1980s college class. Horwitz came into contact with his college copy a few years ago and, after reading a few passages, was hooked. After researching the original dispatches, he made the decision to follow Olmstead's path. As he described it, no bookings, no itinerary, "just a ramble across America with long-dead Fred as my guide."

Horowitz followed Olmstead's off-the-beaten-path journey "through Appalachia, down the Ohio and Mississippi Rivers, into bayou Louisiana, and across Texas to the contested Mexican badlands." In many cases he used similar modes of transportation as did Olmstead.

At this point the book settles into a somewhat regular rhythm of describing Olmstead's journey from point A to point B and his sojourn at point B followed by a description of Horowitz re-tracing the original steps. The description of Olmstead's journey would include the mode of transportation, the duration of the trip, the scenery, and when they (his brother accompanied him for a portion of the trip) ate and slept along the way. A significant portion of the trip was via horseback so many a night was spent camped out in the wilderness. Horowitz would then describe Olmstead's impression of the people, food, and conditions at point B.

Horowitz replication of the trip was rather challenging because of the changes that had occurred over the intervening years: some of the modes of transportation were no longer available between points; some of the towns no longer existed, or existed in a different frame; or there had been significant population change.

Horwitz had the option of using the Olmstead story as a frame and then making the book all about his travel but instead he chose to weave the two stories one into the other. This makes for a very long book and places some patience-demands upon the reader. As a mater of fact, the Olmstead story, as told herein, begins before the trip and ends well after its conclusion; he continues with Olmstead's transition to a landscape architect and his work on Central Park and the difficulties he had with work colleagues and his wife. This additional work appears to be beyond the stated scope of the book but the author would probably say that Olmstead's landscaping "chops" were gained and honed by his observations during his travels in the South and by his conviction that open spaces could bring Northerners together in a way that would be the antithesis of the South.

In a manner similar to Olmstead seeking to understand the perspective of the South in the years prior to the civil war, Horwitz explores political perceptions in the South in the runup to the 2016 election. He found extreme conservatism in East Texas. For example, folks in Houston County saw a 1992 UN Resolution promoting public health, environment, conservation and poverty reduction as being a move to create a Soviet-style uber government. A geologist in Kentucky spoke about his fellow-county-residents thusly: "The know-nothings in this county just seem to be getting stronger. People are proud of their ignorance, and when you challenge it, they fall back on conspiracy theories and fake facts."

At the end of his journeys, Olmstead came away with a new mission: "To fortify the nation against the South's slaveholding elite and feudal ideology, the North must uplift its own citizens to demonstrate the true promise of a free and democratic society." Central Park was his first stab at creating an environment which would advance that mission. Horwitz has no such aspirational experience at the end of his.


©EverythingElse238

Friday, March 29, 2019

Book Review: Yuval Noah Harari's Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind

Yuval Noah Harari's Sapiens is subtitled A Brief History of Humankind and that brevity is accomplished by limiting the scope of the book to the coverage of tectonic events in human history. Historians have developed a facility wherein the history of mankind is partitioned into four discrete, time-based categories -- Cognitive Revolution, Agricultural Revolution, Scientific Revolution, and Industrial Revolution. Yuval has incorporated those characterizations and, within each, identified developments which, in retrospect, have proven to be inflection points in human history. This book is the reader's tour, with Yuval as guide, through that history.

Organisms are first noted on earth 3.8 billion years ago and that, according to Yuval, signals the beginning of biology. These single-celled organisms evolved into more complex and diverse structures, eventually giving rise to the flora and fauna that have occupied the world since. Humans, one of those complex organisms, had its most recent branching on the family tree when it split from a common ancestor with Chimpanzees approximately 6 million years ago.

The genus Homo evolved in Africa and spread to Eurasia 2 million years ago, resulting in the evolution of different Homo species. Homo sapiens evolved in East Africa approximately 200,000 years ago and lived there until a breakout 70,000 years ago.

And that is where the "march of the Sapiens" begins. In the chart below I have provided a timeline, based on the book, of the path that mankind has trod between the start of the Cognitive Revolution and today. In the chart immediately following, I have presented some more details on each of the revolutionary periods.



Prior to the Cognitive Revolution, biological systems determined mankind's destiny. That is, changes to practices and methods only came about as a result of genetic mutations. The Cognitive Revolution resulted in a wave of innovations and new ways of thinking about the world. Other human species could not compete, with Homo Floresiensis finally succumbing 13,000 years ago.

Yuval's position on the Agricultural Revolution is quite unique in the scholarly realm. He sees it as a fraud of epic proportions perpetrated on the neolithic forager. Agriculture promised him stable food supplies but instead delivered: more time spent working; harder work, with a body that is unsuited to that type of labor; less time to spend around the campfire telling tales of the hunt; exposure to diseases that result from living in close proximity to animals and large numbers of other humans; and exposure to the travails of the "luxury trap." He raises a valid question as to whether humans domesticated wheat or wheat domesticated humans. Wheat he said, went from a nondescript, wild, no-prospects member of the neolithic flora to a pampered elite in the plant kingdom who was cared for by humans, protected from birds and animals who may want to do it harm, and most importantly, was able to spread its progeny to the ends of the (at that time) known world. 

The fundamental event of the Scientific Revolution was, according to Yuval, the discovery of America. And it was not obvious that Europe would be the region to make this leap as that era was a "golden age" for the Ottoman (Mediterranean), Safarid (Persia), Mughal (India), and Qing (China) Empires. In 1735 Asia accounted for 80% of the world economy and the combined economies of India and China represented 2/3 of global production. "Europe was an economic dwarf."

At this time the Americas were not known to the world. But soon they were. And they had been discovered by the Europeans, who brought them into the European Empires, delivered large swaths of their inhabitants to the Catholic Church, and extracted enormous wealth from the territories over an extended period of time.

The global center of power shifted to Europe between 1750 and 1850 when they used the wealth from the Americas to conquer large parts of Asia. "By 1900, Europeans firmly controlled the world's economy and most of its territory" and "Today all humans are, to a much greater extent than they want to admit, European in dress, thought, and taste."

There are three key threads running through the book: cooperation as a key building block for human success; "reduction"; and human impact on any environment into which we are introduced.

As relates to the first of these threads, the author describes the use of myths as a means of establishing cooperative networks. Research has shown that, among humans, groups larger than 150 people lose the ability to cooperate based on knowing each other. Getting larger groups to cooperate requires the building of a sense of shared identity. According to Yuval, "The ability to speak about fictions is the most unique feature of Sapiens language. Fiction has enabled us not merely to imagine things, but to do so collectively. We can weave common myths ... such myths give Sapiens the unprecedented ability to cooperate flexibly in large numbers."

The author cites our acceptance of the concept of corporations, the concept of money, the building of the pyramids, etc., all as examples of myth-making and shared beliefs in these myths have been key to Sapiens success.

As it relates to the reduction thread, on the eve of the Agricultural Revolution there were between five and eight million foragers living in Eurasia in thousands of separate tribes, speaking thousands of different languages, and nurturing thousands of different cultures. The Agricultural Revolution itself served as the leading edge of this unifying pressure as it forced a more sedentary lifestyle and the need for interaction to trade surpluses for the things you could not make or the meat you no longer had the time to hunt. 

By 5000 years ago, we had the first Kingdoms, we had seen the introduction of money, and the introduction of polytheistic religions. And these are the three key unification factors. We have gone from Kingdoms to Empires, with incorporated peoples eventually losing their former identities and identifying with the empire. The author uses as an example the fact that at the fall of Rome, all of the peoples that Rome had subjugated did not crawl out from under rocks and seek to reclaim their past heritage. Rather, by this time, their descendants considered themselves Romans.

Humans have moved from polytheistic religions to four religions (two of which are monotheistic) which are dominant in the world. And most of the world today operates under some form of a capitalist system.

The third thread has been Sapiens' impact on the world's flora and fauna. As I have pointed out in a prior post, Sapiens entry into Europe coincided with the demise of a number of other Homo species plus megafauna. The same situation occurred when humans first settled Australia. The megafauna in the Americas died out and so many of the region's inhabitants perished that it is posited that their demise contributed to the Little Ice Age in Europe.

That trend continues even today as many wild animal species are on shaky ground as a result of habitat encroachment, over-fishing, whale-boat collisions, and the potential use of under-water sonic booms in oil exploration.

In each of the areas identified as inflection points on the above timeline, the author identifies the driving factors associated with the issue, the solution set/response, and the impact. His treatment of fire (not on the timeline) illustrates this approach.

In cases where academic consensus on a specific topic has not been attained, Yuval provides the reader with the range of proffered arguments and then identifies his choice and uses that as the jumping-off point for a thread that he wants to pursue.

In a twist to the typical history book, the author uses our current conditions as a launching pad for a discussion as to the potential questions facing us. And while the trip so far has been unmanaged, the risks of continuing along that path are exponential. As we stand on the divide between natural selection and intelligent design, can we allow a Chinese scientist working in a lab in an industrial park to be making genetic changes to humans on his own? As we look to space to create new opportunities, can we allow a world leader to blow up a satellite in space, creating a bunch of potentially dangerous space junk, just to help him in an election?

I would have liked to see more consequential tables and charts than the ones included in the book as they mostly repeat material that is already provided in the text. There are a lot of numbers spread about in the text that would lend themselves to being captured in a table or two. It also would have been interesting to see meaningful comparisons between the Revolutions.

This is not an effort aimed at the halls of academia. It is well researched, and is fully footnoted and bibliographed, but has too much of the authors personal feelings and advocacy positions included to meet the rigid standards of the typical "just-the-facts-ma'am" academic historian. 


This is an engaging and approachable book which undertakes the complex task of delivering a multi-disciplinary history of the world and does so with panache and aplomb. 

@EverythingElse238

Tuesday, March 26, 2019

Children's Book Review: Little Frida by Anthony Browne

I am currently taking a class on Frida Kahlo so I could not resist when I saw this book.

Frida Kahlo has been "a thing" in the art and marketing environments for a number of years now and it seems as though the powers that be have determined that our kids should be included in this phenomenon. Mattel has offered a Frida Kahlo Barbie Doll to market and now Walker Books is introducing a Children's Picture Book titled Little Frida which was authored and illustrated by Anthony Browne.



Anthony Browne is a British writer and illustrator of children's books with fifty books to his credit. He won the biennial international Hans Christian Andersen Award in 2000 for his lasting contribution as a children's illustrator and two Kate Greenaway Medals from the Library Association recognizing the year's best children's book illustrator.

Anthony grounded this effort in  Frida's lived experience as a child. According to the book's inside back cover:
Around the time she had polio, when she was about 6 years old, Frida invented an imaginary friend who could dance without limping. In her diary, she described her first meeting with this companion, from flying through a door she drew on her window, and descending into the earth under the dairy, to sharing secrets with a friend who danced and laughed without making a sound.
The book opens with a poignant first page which describes Frida contracting polio, the physical pain in the aftermath, and the emotional pain from the other kids calling her "peg leg." She was the other. The associated illustration is very Frida with animated cacti dancing with up-thrust arms on an earth whose surface is rent with deep gashes. And there is Frida in her Mexican outfit, flowers in her hair, and one leg markedly different from the other. The sun is low in the sky and casts a long shadow. The houses of the village are in the background.

The illustrations in this book are magnificent, either hewing to a Frida painting or looking like something that Frida would have done. One of his illustrations is of Frida dreaming of piloting a plane: her fuselage is a pear; the nose cone is one-third of an orange; the wings are the bottom halves of two bananas with each end pointing in opposite directions; the front landing gear is represented by two cherries while the rear is represented by a single grape; strawberries and a water melon make up the tail assembly. A parrot is the co-pilot. This is not surreal; it is sur-fruity.

Another two-page illustration shows the gashed earth with mountains in the background. The sun (early Diego) is bright orange on the right page with a shimmering silver moon on the left. Way in the distance, as Frida runs across the rent earth, is a dairy. Frida crawls through a door into the dairy and falls down a pink tunnel which has either two red ribbons, or two blood tracks, along the side; again, evocative of the adult Frida.

And then she meets this girl -- the imaginary friend -- who is wearing clothing that tags the illustration as a precursor of the Frida Kahlo painting titled The Two Fridas. And then they sit and it is a "mini-me" version of The Two Fridas as they join one set of hands and, in the other, hold opposite ends of a string which is colored 1/2 red and 1/2 white.

Frida flies back home to a blue house whose courtyard is bedecked with flowers of all types and colors.

The final illustration has Frida drawing an eye on a notepad. The background is filled with all kind of trees and leaves upon which the Frida Kahlo menagerie roams.

This is a great book. It has a storyline that will appeal to the kids but also has a sophisticated Kahlo presentation which will appeal to the parent who will be reading the book to the child.

@EverythingElse238

In the Footsteps of Piero della Francesca: Queen of Sheba, King Solomon, and Burial of the Wood

Just below the Death of Adam in Basilica di San Francesca's Bacci Chapel is the two-scene fresco Procession of the Queen of Sheba and M...