Saturday, November 1, 2025

In the Footsteps of Piero della Francesca: Meetup and the Maddalena

Piero della Francesca's import to pre-Renaissance art and how I became involved in a trip to walk in his footsteps have previously been detailed. Now for the journey.

What I will call Day 0 of the trip entailed traveling from one's source-location to Hotel Tiferno in Citta di Castello, said hotel serving the role of Expeditionary HQ. Most of the trip participants were coming in from England and were scheduled to travel together on a BA flight to Bologna and then by coach to Citta di Castello. I will come back to that later.

I had flown into Rome earlier in pursuit of some church-bound Caravaggio paintings and then had gone on to Siena to visit some of the city's famous art repositories. My trip to Città, therefore, originated in Siena. Citta di Castello is almost due east of Siena but, due to intervening mountains, public transportation between the two locations is both circuitous and time-consuming. After exploring a number of alternatives, I settled on the train between Siena and Arezzo and a private car (NCC) between Arezzo and Hotel Tiferno. This arrangement still necessitated going north to Florence and then southeast to Arezzo  but saved significant time over taking the train from Florence to Citta di Castello. The chart below shows the journey.


I left Siena early enough to get to Hotel Tiferno for a meet-and-greet scheduled for 6:30 pm. Unfortunately, BA cancelled the flight from Heathrow and the organizers had to scramble for alternate arrangements. Fortunately they were able to get everyone to the hotel; ragged, tired, and late though they were. The meet-and-greet was dispensed with and the group dinner started after 8:30 pm.

Day 1 began with a breakfast in the hotel dining room followed by a pre-trip lecture by Tour Tutor Agnes Crawford.

Agnes Crawford and Day 1 lecture

This was the only "day-of" lecture of the entire trip; all subsequent lectures were delivered on the evening of the day prior to the tour. The intent of the lecture was to provide insight into our destinations and the Piero piece(s) we would see once there.

Our Day 1 journey entailed travel to Arezzo to see Piero works at the Cathedral of San Donato and the Basilica of San Francesca. This was a return journey for me as I had traveled from Arezzo to Città on the preceding day. We boarded our coach filled with anticipation. Piero's footsteps loomed large ahead of us.

After about 45 minutes of travel, we arrived at Arezzo.


We were dropped off at the bottom of the hill and made our way to the Cathedral of San Donato. 

Cathedral of San Donato, Arezzo

This cathedral, dedicated to Saints Donatus and Peter, is the largest Christian building in Arezzo and can trace its roots all the way back to the end of the 13th century. The original Arezzo Cathedral had been built nearby over the burial place of Saint Donatus, Arezzo's patron saint. In the 13th century the Pope ordered that the cathedral be moved to its current location within the town walls. Construction began in the 13th century but was sporadic with the facade only completed at the beginning of the 20th century. Due to its extended period of construction, it is a blend of architectural styles. According to Audiala.com: "The Duomo di Arezzo, as it stands today, is not a pure representation of any single architectural style. Instead, it stands as a fascinating blend of Romanesque, Gothic, and Renaissance elements, each layer telling a story of the city's rich past. This fusion of styles, rather than creating a sense of disharmony, contributes to the Duomo's unique charm and visual appeal."

The Cathedral was beautifully appointed with stunning ceilings, stained-glass windows, and wall-mounted or frescoed paintings. 






But we were here to see Piero della Francesco's work: Santa Maria Maddalena.

Piero della Francesca,
  Santa Maria Maddalena, 1459.
Viewed in situ 9/27/2025

Piero was given the commission for this effort more or less at the same time that he was working on the final scenes of the cycle of the Legend of the True Cross. According to the accompanying literature:

The fresco, mentioned by Giorgio Vasari, is next to the vestry door and neatly hidden by the fourteenth-century cenotaph of Bishop Tarlati, which was moved here in 1783, destroying the ancient chapel. It was painted by Piero della Francesca before 1459, the year the great painter had probably completed the cycle of the Legend of the True Cross in the Church of Saint Francesco in Arezzo. The Magdalene is portrayed according to the ancient iconography, her long hair worn loose, while holding in her hand the container of ointments that she would then rub on Jesus' body in the Holy Sepulchre. The Saint, set within a classical-style Renaissance arch, embellished by an extremely elegant frieze, must have been represented on a blue background of which some traces remain, just as the gold of the halo has fallen off.
Not dissimilar to early 16th-century Venetian works, the painting relies on large patches of bright colors which are also rich in symbolism: green for hope; white for faith; and red for charity. The painterly skills of the artist are manifested in the shining light reflected on the glass container in the subject's hand and the strand by strand depiction of her hair on her shoulders. These reflect the attention to detail typical of the artist's mature works.

One source has described Magdalene's look as being "triumphant, rather than penitent" and as looking down at the viewer in a deep and expressive manner with her beauty being "elegant, almost transcendent."

According to centopassidalduomo.it, "Mary Magdalene ... portrayed in a state of deep reflection and spirituality, becomes an emblem of a beauty that transcends mere physical esthetics and succeds in reaching to the soul, demonstrating Piero's ability to fuse technical innovations with profound sensitivity."

A third source: "Piero della Francesca's "Maddalena" is recognized as an incredible masterpiece of the Renaissance, marking a crucial phase in the artistic and cultural revolution of that era ... the Fresco is positioned in a period of intense creative expression for artist, highlighting  a moment of synthesis between his investigations into perspective, the use of lighting and human portraiture."

*********************************************************************************************************

This was breathtaking. This piece was stunningly beautiful and had rested in this space, regally looking down at viewers, for almost 500 years. We needed a break to contemplate this before going on to see the Legend of the True Cross. A story that I will pick up on a subsequent post.


Friday, October 24, 2025

Piero della Francesca: Life highlights

I was ready to follow in the Footsteps of Piero della Francesca. I had "happened" on this small, English company (Learn Italy) specializing in leisurely educational tours focused on Italian history, art, and culture; had committed to their Piero della Francesca tour; and had completed a fair amount of preparatory work. Now it was time to embark. But before I do, a brief introduction to the painter is in order.

Piero della Francesca 
Piero was born in Sansepolcro (then known as Borgo San Sepolcro) sometime around 1415. 



His family was prosperous, engaged, as they were, in the leather and indigo industries. Being the son of a merchant, Piero received training in mathematics and those skills were reflected in his work. With his family background, and education, it would have been normal for Piero to enter the family business. But this was not to be. He would use his mathematical education to great benefit in his chosen profession. 

Portrait of Piero della Francesca
from a 1648 edition of 
The Lives
(
Wikipedia)

A summary of key aspects of the painter's life is presented in the chart below.


Piero is, today, "regarded as a genius and a foundational artist of the Early Renaissance period" and, indeed, was held in the highest esteem while alive. His friend -- and a great mathematician -- Luca Paciola called him 'el monarchs de la pittura (the monarch of painting). His works disappeared from radar screens in the 17th century, however, only re-emerging with the European and American Grand Tours of Europe. His works gained greater acclaim, and his resurrection more sustained, with the 1991 John Pope-Hennesey lecture at the New York's Metropolitan Museum of Art.

In describing the painter, Natalia Iacobelli, writing in dailyartmagazine.com, states thusly:
Piero della Francesca was not only an accomplished artist of the Early Renaissance, but also one of the greatest mathematicians of his day. His works reveal his innovative mind and his meticulous understanding of space, perspective, and proportion. Piero della Francesca was at the cutting edge of Humanism, writing extensively on the topics of arithmetic and geometry. His transfixing compositions built on geometric principles demonstrate his mathematical prowess and his sensibility of the classical past.
**********************************************************************************************************
With some perspective on the painter, you are now ready to accompany me in his footsteps.



 

Wednesday, October 15, 2025

In the Steps of Piero della Francesca: The prequel

I was on a 2011 Bordeaux Index tour of Bolgheri and Montalcino when a Twitter friend (yes, I too used to be on that platform) Laura Rose-Gray, then General Manager of boutique Brunello di Montalcino winery Il Palazzone, reached out to invite me to visit the winery. By this time we had completed our visits in Montalcino and were well on our way to Florence so I regretfully declined and promised that I would do so the next time that I was in the area. 

The author with Laura Rose-Gray in Perugia

And thus began a long and fruitful (for me) online relationship. Laura was critical to my writings on Brunello di Montalcino by providing insights into trends, movers and shakers, and appellation and terroir issues. My writings in this area would have been fewer, and of lesser quality, if I had not had the good fortune of crossing virtual paths with her. I did eventually visit the estate but, a few days before my arrival, Laura's son fell ill and she had to be away. Her good friend Esther Juergens hosted me on the trip in her stead.

Il Palazzone had been owned since 2000 by the former Time Warner Executive Richard Parsons. He elevated Laura to GM in 2008. He sold the business in 2021 and the new owners wanted to be more active in running the place so Laura moved on (My Montalcino output has not recovered to this day). She first wrote the book that had been struggling for years to get out (The Magpie's Guide to Montalcino) and then spent a fair amount of time on promotional tours.  She also began doing consulting work which drew on her winery experience and expertise. 

Shortly after Richard Parsons bought Il Palazzone (2002, to be exact), Laura's father, Martin Gray, Head of the Department of English Studies at the University of Stirling, founded Learn Italy: "a small British company based in Oxford, offering study holidays that combine relaxation with learning" with a focus on Italy. Martin has, through the years, encouraged Laura to become involved in the business. She had an excuse: she was busy running Il Palazzone. Well she no longer had that excuse so she is helping run Learn Italy "navigating the organizational aspects, and accompanying most trips."

I was unaware of this aspect of Laura's life until she commented on one of my many online art posts. In the ensuing discussion I found out about her interest in art, the fact that she had just completed a Renaissance art course, and her involvement with Learn Italy. I requested a catalog and, upon receipt, immediately homed in on the "In the Footsteps of Piero della Francesca" offering which promised "Visits to find his paintings in Arezzo, Sanseplocro, Urbino, Perugia, and Monterchi." I was in.

Learn Italy did an awesome job of prepping us for the tour, including providing us with a list of material to read ahead of time.

In addition, I pursued other sources of information. For example I watched a number of You Tube videos including:

  • In the Footseps of Piero della Francesca, Muscarelle Museum of Art
  • Piero della Francesca: A quiet revolutionary, National Gallery
  • Frick Collection Lectures around its 2013 Piero della Francesca exhibition.

In addition to the above I sought out Piero della Francesca holdings in museums for deeper study. I began with the Frick holdings.

The Frick Collection and The Augustinian Altarpiece

I encountered four Piero della Francesca pieces on my visit to the re-opening of the Frick Collection in April of 2025.  Picture-taking is not allowed at the Frick so I have used publicly available images to represent the Piero paintings that  I have viewed at that institution. All of these pieces were derived from the Augustinian Altarpiece (discussed later).

Piero della Francesca, Saint Augustinian,
Polyptych of Saint Augustine,1469,
tempera on wood, 39 x 28 cm,
The Frick Collection, NY. Viewed in situ 4/17/25.

The Augustinian Nun (Saint Monica),
Polyptych of Saint Augustine, 1469,
tempera on wood, 39 x 28 cm,
The Frick Collection, NY. Viewed in situ 4/17/25

Crucifixion, Polyptych of St. Augustine”, 1469, tempera
on wood, 37.47 x 41.12 cm, The Frick Collection, NY. 
Viewed in situ 4/17/25.

Saint John the Evangelist,
1454–69
Oil and tempera with traces of gold
on poplar panel 
134 x 62.2 cm
The Frick Collection, New York.
Viewed in situ 4/17/25

In addition to the pieces at the Frick, I caught another piece from the Augustinian Altarpiece at the National Gallery in Washington, D.C. The piece, Saint Apollonia, is shown below.

Piero della Francesca, Saint Apollonia,
Polyptych of Saint Augustine, 1469,
tempera on wood, 39 x 28 cm,
National Gallery of Art, Washington. 
Seen in situ 8/26/25.

Further investigation showed that Frick had hosted an exhibition of 7 pieces of the Augustinian Altarpiece — six of which are based in the US — in 2013 and I dove into the archives to study the work done around that exhibition. 

In 1454, Angelo di Giovanni di Simone d'Angelo commissioned a polyptych from Piero della Francesca for the High Altar of St Agostino in Borgo Sansepolchro. The polyptych was intended to fulfill the wishes of his late brother Simone and his widow Giovanna to procure spiritual benefits for the donor and his forbears.

The structural framework of the altarpiece had a history prior to Piero's storied work. The Franciscans had had the structure built in the early 1430s to support paintings by Antonio d'Anghari and Piero had worked with him to gesso the piece. The effort was abandoned after the Franciscans hired Sassetta to do the work instead.

In 1451 the Franciscans sold the framework to Angelo Giovanni di Simone. It was more than 40 years old when Piero began working on it as the mainstay of the Augustinian High Altar. The piece was completed in 1469 and served as the High Altar until it was disassembled in 1555 when the Augustinians moved. The 30 panels were dispersed, with eight currently housed in institutions in Europe and the US.

Previous attempts  have been made to unite the surviving pieces. The most successful, prior to the Poldi Pozzoli effort, was the Frick exhibition which displayed all of the pieces with the exception of the Poldi holding. When the Frick announced its pending closure for renovation, Poldi Pozzoli reached out to that institution and other holders with hosting requests. Those requests were granted and the pieces were reunited in an exhibition at Poldi Pozzi that ran from March 20 to June 24, 2024.

Baptism of Christ

I encountered Baptism of Christ at the National Gallery. The analysis included on the chart below draws heavily on the museum’s write-ups plus associated lectures.

Armed with the above, we launched into the program. I will report on same in upcoming posts.

Friday, October 10, 2025

Caravaggio: Riding the wave

I visited the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition earlier this year in Rome and had a number of issues with it. One of my peeves was the organization of painter's oeuvre.  In a series of posts, I am attempting to place the paintings from the 2025 exhibition, and Caravaggio works that I have seen post that visit, into a more easily understood framework. This post continues that series.  

Caravaggio's work in the Contarelli Chapel received widespread acclaim and lifted him up on a wave that he rode with gusto until he came crashing back to earth in 1606. 

The first evidence of Caravaggio's newfound fame was a commission from Monsignor Tibero Cesari -- Treasurer-General to Pope Clement VIII -- to provide two paintings for the side panels of the Cesari Chapel of the Basilica di Santa Maria del Popolo. Cesari had recently bought the patronage rights to the chapel and commissioned Carracci and Caravaggio to provide the necessary artwork. Caravaggio's two paintings were supposed to commemorate Saints Peter and Paul but his first two submittals (Crucifixion of Saint Peter, c. 1600 - 1601 and Conversion of Saul, c. 1600 - 01) were not accepted. It is thought that Caravaggio painted the pieces prior to getting accurate measurements and the finished paintings did not fit the space. 

Basilica di Santa Maria del Popolo

These two paintings were subsequently bought by the Catholic Cardinal Giacomo Sennesia with the surviving one -- Conversion of Saul -- now resident in the Nicoletta Odescalchi Collection and shown at Caravaggio 2025. The two rejected paintings were replaced with Conversion on the Way to Damascus, 1601 and Crucifixion of St Peter, 1601. Both of these paintings were accepted and are present in the named chapel to this day.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Conversion of Saul, 1600 - 01
(Nicoletta Odescalchi collection, Rome;
viewed at the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition,
7/18/2025)

The Conversion of St. Paul has the belly of the horse as the central point with St Paul almost out of the picture at the bottom of the frame. The foreshortened St Paul is held down by the power of the blinding light while the groom seems to be less aware than the horse of what is happening. 

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Conversion on the Way to Damascus, 1601
(Basilica di Santa Maria del Popolo, Rome;
viewed in situ, 9/24/2025)

According to Dr Ruggiero, the Crucifixion of St. Peter is one of the most moving works in the history of art. The burliness of the models suggest neighborhood recruits and the entire scene is rendered up close and personal to the viewer. The single rock is the only item that gives a sense of where we are. Dr Ruggiero suggested that it could also be a play on Peter as the rock on which the church will be built.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Crucifixion of St Peter, 1601
(Basilica di Santa Maria del Popolo, Rome;
viewed in situ, 9/24/2025)

Neither of the two Cerasi Chapel paintings were included in the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition.

Two of Jesus' disciples were walking to Emmaus and are joined by a third traveler. This traveler is Jesus but he remains unrecognized until he reveals himself to the disciples while they are having dinner at an Inn in the town of Emmaus. According to the National Gallery, The Supper at Emmaus, 1601 was "painted at the height of Caravaggio's fame," was recorded at the Villa Borghese (Rome) in 1650 (likely having been in the collection of Cardinal Scipione Borghese, who died in 1633), and listed in a Borghese inventory of 1693.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, The Supper at
Emmaus
, 1601 (National Gallery of Art, London;
viewed in situ, 12/5/2024)

The museum sees the painting as "among his most impressive domestic religious pictures." The symbolism associated with the painting is illustrated below.

The Taking of Christ was painted for the Roman Marquis Ciriaco Mattei and continued the flurry of commissions that fell into Caravaggio's lap following his Contarelli Chapel success. The figures, according to the National Gallery of Ireland (the home of the painting), are placed close to the picture plane and "a strong light-and-dark contrast" gives the scene an" extraordinary sense of drama." In the painting, Judas has identified Jesus with a kiss and the Temple Guards are moving in for the arrest. John The Evangelist flees the scene in disarray at the far left while Caravaggio peers in on the far right.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
The Taking of Christ, 1602
(National Gallery of Ireland, Dublin;
viewed at the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition,
7/18/2025)

This painting has led a storied life. It remained in the Mattei Family for over 200 years. By the second half of the 18th Century a number of the Mattei paintings were reattributed, including the Caravaggio which was attributed to a Dutch Caravaggiste named Gerrit van Honthorst. In 1602 the painting was sold to William Hamilton Nisbett, a wealthy Scottish art collector doing business in Rome. The painting remained in his family for 119 years after which it was sold at auction in 1921 and again in 1922. Post the final auction it was held by Major Charles Hubert Francis Noel. In 1924 it was acquired by Dr Marie Lea-Wilson who brought it to Ireland. In the 1930s Dr Lea-Wilson presented the painting to the Jesuit Fathers of Leeson Street in Dublin where it hung in their dining room for 50 years. In 1990 Father Noel Barber contacted the National Gallery of Ireland to have its holdings assessed. Three years of careful study followed and the painting was once again attributed to Caravaggio and was placed on long-term loan to the National Galley of Ireland.

The Crowning of Thorns (1603), resident in Vienna's Kunthistorisches Museum, is one of two Caravaggio works treating this subject (The other is at the Cariprato Bank in Prato). This painting originated from the collection of Vincenzo Giustiniani who had, since about 1600, begun compiling "the most influential collection of European Baroque Art." The painting was mentioned in the collection inventory as a piece designed to be hung over a doorway.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
The Crowning of Thorns, 1603 (Kunthistorisches
Museum, Vienna; viewed at the exhibition From
Vienna to Rome:Habsburg Masterpieces from the
Kunthistorisches Museum, Museo del Corso;
4/18/2026)

According to the wall poster accompanying the piece, it "... is among the most powerful representations of Christ's suffering in Caravaggio's oeuvre. After his interrogation before Pilate, Christ was publicly humiliated with a crown of thorns, a mock sceptre, and a red cloak. Caravaggio endows him with a delicate complexion that stands in stark contrast to the sun-tanned bodies of his tormentors. His bare neck, violently forced into a horizontal position, underscores the brutality of the event; yet he appears curiously untouched by the mechanical forces visibly acting upon him."

There had been some disagreement as to the period in which the work was painted but "20th century scholarship has firmly established the Vienna version's autograph status through technical analysis and stylistic comparison that align it with Caravaggio's Roman period output around 1602 - 1604."

The painting was acquired in 1869 in Rome by Baron Ludwig von Lebzeltern for the Imperial Gallery. It arrived in Vienna on April 16, 1816.

Saint John the Baptist in the Wilderness, 1602 - 04, is one of about eight Caravaggio paintings dealing with this topic. The painting was initially commissioned by the banker Ottavio Costa who thought to send it to a small church in Liguria. He was unable to let the painting go, however, and kept it with him in Rome all his life.

The subject is shown "sitting on a rock, leaning on his reed cross, caught in. a moment of deep meditation. Light and shadow, engulfing the ribcage and falling across the eyes, wrestle on the figure of this saint ..."

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Saint John the Baptist in the Wilderness, c. 1602 - 04
(The Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas City, MO;
viewed at the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition,
7/18/2025)

I visited the Vatican Museums in search of The Entombment but the painting was, disappointingly, out for restoration and its place had been taken by a Gobelins Manufactory tapestry created in 1852 - 55 and based on the Master's painting. I was forced to visit the Vatican Museums website to view a picture of the Caravaggio piece. 

According to the museum, the Entombment (also called Deposition) was commissioned by Girolamo Vittrice for his family chapel in the church of Santa Maria in Vallicella. This painting had been among the works transferred to Paris in 1787 as a result of the Treaty of Tolentino but had been returned to Rome after Napoleon's fall. In Rome it was housed in Pope Pius VIIs Pinacoteca.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
The Entombment of Christ, c. 1602 - 04
(Pinacoteca Vaticana, Rome)

The Entombment shows Jesus about to be laid on the Anointing Stone (the stone that will seal the tomb) by John and Nicodemus while the Virgin Mother, Mary Magdalene, and Mary of Cleophus (with arms upraised) bear witness. The painting is characterized by the artists trademark tenebrism with the light illuminating the stark reality of the scene: a stone seemingly about to exit the picture frame; musculature; veins; defined rib cage; the dead weight of Jesus' body; John's fingers intruding into the wound in Jesus' side; the naturalness of the fall of his lifeless arm; the seeming extended middle finger; the everydayness of the face looking towards the viewer; the sorrow etched on the faces of the Virgin and Mary Magdalene; and the unshod feet of the bearer.

The major design construct is an upward right diagonal beginning at the point of Jesus' head.

In Caravaggio's Sacrifice of Isaac, a black-winged angel stays Abraham's knife-wielding right hand while Isaac stares out at us with a look of abject terror and a scream to match. The sheep looks imploringly at Abraham as if to say "You've got the wrong guy buddy."The action is taking place on high ground as there are buildings below the event level.While this event took place somewhere in today's Middle East, the background is reminiscent of a Renaissance Tuscan countryside.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Sacrifice of Isaac, 1603 - 04 (Uffizi, Florence;
viewed in situ, 10/2/2025)

Another treatment of John the Baptist in the Wilderness (1604 - 06). This one features a younger-faced John stripped of his ever-present camel skin robe and with elements of the cross cut off by the edge of the painting.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
John the Baptist (John in the Wilderness), c. 1604 - 1606
(Galleria Nazionale d'Arte Antica, Rome;
viewed at the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition,
7/18/2025)

Just after completing the work on the Cerasi Chapel, Caravaggio was commissioned by Laerzio Cherubini to produce a painting on the death of the Virgin for the altar on his family chapel in the Carmelite church of Santa Maria della Scala in Trastavere.

Catholic dogma at the time had coalesced around the sentiment that Mary had been “assumed into heaven prior to her burial” but in his The Death of a Virgin, Caravaggio treated the scene as “ if it were simply the death of a beloved middle-aged woman.” The thin halo around her head is the only allusion to her holiness and status as the mother of Jesus. Mary Magdalene is bent over to the left of the body and we can assume that the kneeling young man is St. John the Beloved. Saint Peter is one of the “grandfatherly figures” but beyond that the apostles are unidentified.

Mary forms the only horizontal in a forest of verticals and her body is the only one shown in its entirety. Only she is fully illuminated. Mary’s depiction illustrates “Caravaggio’s commitment to naturalism and a more realistic portrayal of Christian imagery.” 

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
The Death of the Virgin, 1601 - 06 (Louvre, Paris;
viewed in situ, 12/11/2025)

The painting was rejected by the Fathers of Santa Maria della Scala in 1606 and replaced by a more conventional treatment of the subject by Carlo Saraceni. Caravaggio’s version was purchased by Vincenzo Gonzaga — on the recommendation of Rubens — and later came into the possession of The Louvre.

Borghese Galleria, home to the Madonna and Child with Saint Anne (Madonna dei Palafrenieri), 1605 - 06, describes the piece as "one of Caravaggio's most famous mature religious works." This piece was originally intended for the altar of the Archconfraternity of the Papal Grooms but was declined by the patrons for unstated reasons. It should be noted that the depiction of the Virgin Mother in this piece was "atypical" for the period. The completion date is baselined by a receipt for payment to the artist dated April 8, 1606, less than 2 months before life-changing events overtook him. Cardinal Scipione Borghese eventually bought the painting.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Madonna and Child with Saint Anne,
  
1605 - 06 (Galleria Borghese;
viewed in situ, 8/30/2026)

The painting, exhibiting the characteristic Caravaggio tenebrism,  shows the Virgin, assisted by her unclothed, uncircumcised son, trampling a writhing snake underfoot while Saint Ann bears witness to the event. A snake symbolized evil or original sin. Both mother and child are unshod and the hair of Jesus has a decidedly reddish tint. The person depicting the Virgin in this painting is thought to be the same model appearing as the Madonna di Loreto in the Caravaggio's work in Rome's Sant'Agostino church.

Recent conservation work on the painting has revealed incisions on the canvas and, according to Galleria Borghesi, this is a feature of the Lombard Master's work. The conservation effort also shows that the halos of the Virgin and Saint Anne were initially at the same level.

Saint Jerome Writing was prepared by Caravaggio in fulfillment of a commission for Cardinal Scipione Borghese. According to The Met, Borghese (1576 - 1633) "was one of the wealthiest and most powerful men in Rome during the first third of the seventeenth century. An astute art collector, he commissioned sculptures that would come to define the Baroque movement."

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, Saint Jerome
Writing
, c. 1606 (Galleria Borghese, Rome; viewed
in situ August 30, 2026)

The work shows an aged St Jerome on the right-hand-side of the painting peering intently onto a page of a thick tome. He has a hint of a halo above his head and his left shoulder, back, and lower body are covered by a voluminous red garment. His outstretched arm appears to be resting on the opened page from which he is reading. The thumb and forefinger lightly embrace a quill which appears silvery in the cast light. That light also illuminates his right arm, face, and chest as well as part of the book. There appears to be a malformation of the forearm. Saint Jerome is depicted as a scholar herein; according to tradition, he had translated the Holy Scripture from Greek to Latin. In the days prior to the Reformation, he would be shown with a Lion and a cardinal's hat. The Reformers sought to return religious art to its foundations hence the presentation of the saint in his raison d' etré (Galleria Borghese).

At the other end of the solid brown wooden table is another open book which, given the proximity of the quill, one can conjecture, is the recipient of the written word. Positioned on that book is a skull which, when paired with the grey-white cloth draping down from the table, has the look of a person surveying the Saint's work.

In typical mature Carravagio style, the background is darkened, the areas of focus sharply lit, and there is a profusion of shadow. There is not much separation between the painted scene and the viewer.

The painting provides us with a series of contrasts: life (albeit aged) in the person of the saint versus the promise of death embodied in the skull; warm colors on the Saint's side versus a dull grayness on the other; and, finally, a temporal contrast with the skull representing the past and the saint representing the present.

There has been some discussion as to the completeness of this painting. Antonio Ionnelli, writing in the Galleria Borghese Catalog Entry: "The limited quantity of paint used in the work, the summary representation of some details -- such as the irregularity of the beard and the rapid execution of the cassock -- as well as several elements that seem to indicate that the painter had second thoughts -- evident in the left hand, right arm, the face and the pose of the saint -- inclined Maurizio Marini to propose that the painting was unfinished. In 1989, however, Mia Cinotti rejected this idea."

This work had been attributed to Caravaggio at least since 1633 and was recorded as hanging in the premises in the middle of the 17th century. Despite the foregoing, it was mistakenly attributed to Jusepe de Ribera in 1790 and only regained its rightful authorship when it was included in a 1951 Roberto Longhi exhibition of Caravaggio works.

In 1603 Ermete Cavalleti became patron of the Chapel of the Madonna of Loreto in the Basilica di Sant'Agostino and commissioned a painting from Caravaggio which would represent the Madonna of the Pilgrims (also known as the Madonna of Loreto). The final product was placed in the chapel at the beginning of 1606.

Basilica di Sant'Agostino

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio,
Madonna of the Pilgrims (Madonna of Loreto),
1604 - 06 (Sant'Agostino, Rome;
viewed in situ, 9/24/2025)

It was shortly after the completion of the Madonna of Loreto that things came crashing down around Caravaggio's head. He had always been on the wrong side of the law (Google Arts and Culture):
  • He was in and out of prison
  • He carried a sword
  • He loafed about taverns
  • He did not pay his rent for 6 months
  • He harassed women
  • He harassed anyone who slighted him
  • He assaulted waiters, notaries and public officers.
But all that paled in comparison to the events of May 28th, 1606 when he killed Ranuccio Tomassoni in a duel and was sentenced to death by beheading. Caravaggio had been befriended by Costanza, daughter  of Marcantonio II of the famed and respected Colonna Family, and had visited the family palace in Rome in the past. And it was there that he sought refuge. 

At this time Caravaggio was no longer riding the wave; he was now embarked on the life of a man on the run.

Saturday, October 4, 2025

Caravaggio: Scaling the Heights

The Caravaggio 2025 exhibition placed the paintings on show into categories with which I remain less-than-thrilled. For example, the paintings presented under the heading “Invigorating the Dark Shades,” are, to my mind, actually a subset of the earliest-mentioned category “Making a Name for Himself in Rome” because Caravaggio did not really become widely known until after his completion of the paintings in the Contarelli Chapel. 

I traveled to a number of churches in Rome — the homes of these period pieces — so that (i) I could have pictorial evidence of their existence and (ii) to slot them into this discussion of the works of the Master. I title these paintings that bring Caravaggio fame “Caravaggio: Scaling the Heights.”

The first of these paintings was installed at the Contarelli Chapel of San Luis dei Francesi. This chapel was named after Matteo Contarelli, a Frenchman from Anjou and Cardinal Datary for Pope Gregory XIII. Contarelli had personally been involved with the design of the chapel since 1563 but died in 1585 prior to its completion. After his death, the Executor of his estate, and the congregation, resumed the project sometime between 1591 and 1593. They modified the initial plan to instead have Cavalier d’ Arpino work in the vaults and lunettes while the Flemish sculptor Jacob Cobert would work on the altar statue. This plan was itself abandoned in favor of a plan for paintings by Caravaggio. 

In 1599, thanks to the intervention of Cardinal Francesco Maria del Monte, Caravaggio received his first public commission to paint canvases for the Contarelli chapel in the church of San Luigi dei Francesi. The cycle, focused on the life of Saint Matthew, was not only a challenge for Merisi, who had to grapple with paintings of "historia" for the first time, it represents a crucial watershed in his production because, from that moment on, Caravaggio painted almost only religious paintings, and in them, we begin to see that "tragic" style that came to characterize his production. This chapel features some of the most emblematic religious-themed works of the mature Merisi.

The first painting that he did was the Martydom of St. Matthew. The painting captures the scene after Matthew had already been struck. He is reaching upwards for the palm, the symbol of martyrdom. Caravaggio can be seen leaning in from the back left. 



Contarelli Chapel

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, 
The Martyrdom of St. Matthew, 1599 - 1602
(San Luigi dei Francesi, Rome; viewed in situ, 9/24/2025)

According to the literature accompanying the display, “The great innovation … lies in the use of light in the composition: the natural light coming through the window and the light masterfully rendered in the painting by Caravaggio’s genius.”

The most famous of the paintings in the chapel, according to Dr. Rocky Ruggiero, is the Calling of St. Matthew. 

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, 
The Calling of St. Matthew, 1599 - 1600
(San Luigi dei Francesi, Rome; viewed in situ, 9/24/2025)

I have previously analyzed this painting and present the results herein.


He had two passes at St. Matthew and the Angel for the altarpiece. The first effort was rejected because it did not present St Matthew in the finest light. That piece was destroyed in Berlin in 1942. The second version is shown below where St Matthew writes his gospel, inspired by an angel.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, 
St. Matthew and the Angel, 1602
(San Luigi dei Francesi, Rome; viewed 
in situ, 9/24/2025)

The painting John the Baptist (1602) resident in the Capitoline Museum is one of eight works by Caravaggio of this subject. According to the side panel:
The light comes from the top left and strikes the youth's nude back, part of his face, and his right leg, but leaving the rest of the body in shadow. In the work, Caravaggio makes the divine human and the human divine: Saint John is re-embodied as a grinning, impish and sensual youth, expressing with his whole body the joy of living. The boy in his turn interprets a young saint still unaware of his dramatic destiny. The picture appears to merge suddenly from the darkness, and to take sudden shape before our eyes in a real space, under a real light, and in real time -- a figure it seems we can almost touch.
Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, 
John the Baptist, 1602
(Musei Capitoline, Rome; viewed
in situ, 4/18/2026)

The young Baptist is missing the usual identifying attributes --- bowl, reed cross, lamb -- with the lamb being substituted by a Ram. It is speculated thatthe Baptist's pose was inspired by Michelangelo's Ignudi on the Sistine Chapel.

The most likely provenance of the piece is as follows:
  • Commissioned by Ciriaco Mattei
  • Given to him by his son Giovanni Battista
  • Bequeathed by the son to Cardinal del Monte in Wills of January 1623 and June 1624
  • Listed in the del Monte inventory of 1627
  • Sold at the del Monte sale of 1628 to Cardinal Pio
  • Sold by the Pio family to Pope Benedict XIV in 1749/50  to be lodged in the newly founded Capitoline Museum.
What is considered a copy of this painting is resident in the Donna Pamphilj Gallery in Rome and was viewed on the same day as the painting above.

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, 
John the Baptist, 1602
(Pamphilj Gallery, Rome; viewed
in situ, 4/18/2026)

By this time Carravaggio had gained critical and popular acclaim.  The next phase of his career, as I see it, was him "riding the wave."

Wednesday, August 27, 2025

Judith beheading Holofernes: Caravaggio and Artemisia Gentileschi

Both Caravaggio and Artemisia Gentileschi (twice) executed paintings of the biblical story of Judith beheading the Assyrian general Holofernes. I will compare these representations but will first document why this particular comparison is especially interesting.

Artemisia Gentileschi was a Caravaggisti. Caravaggio had been too busy getting into trouble and running from the law -- and developing phenomenal works of art during the dead periods --to establish a school or to take on students. Rather, subsequent adherence to his style was organic.

According to worldatlas.com, "Caravaggisti art refers to an artistic movement that resulted in a new Baroque painting style" based on the work of Caravaggio and characterized by the use of tenebrism ("the use of profound shadowing and high contrast between areas of light and dark") and chiaroscuro (use of "light and shadows to create a three-dimensional appearance").

The painters who adopted Caravaggio's techniques were called Caravaggisti. Some adopted his techniques for a portion of their careers while others devoted their entire lives to modeling his style. 

The chart below shows the elements of Caravaggio's style in the southwestern quadrant and its further spread along the bottom portion. Style adherents are shown in the upper portions of the chart.

Orazio Gentileschi, the father of Artemisia, became a close associate of Caravaggio after seeing the latter’s 1600 paintings. Gentileschi’s paintings post-1600 began to incorporate elements of the Caravaggio approach (NGA, Christiansen and Mann):

  • Use of models
  • Dramatic lighting
  • Simplified compositional structures with a restricted number of figures close to the picture plane
  • Use of dramatic, unconventional gestures and monumental composition
  • Uncompromising realism and contemporary representation of figure types.

Even though Orazio backslid, he still enjoys special prominence when discussions arise re Caravaggisti active in the first two decades of the 17th century. He was the first to respond to the shift but he also influenced others, notably Bartolomeo Lavarozzi (1590 - 1625), Orazio Riminaldi (1593 - 1630), and Giovann Francesco Guerreiri (1589 - 1655/1659), Italians all. He also influenced Hendrik Terbruggen who the took the style back to Utrecht. But, by far, his most prominent student was his daughter Artemisia.

The Story behind the Paintings
Holofernes, an Assyrian general, had been sent by King Nebuchadnezzar to “teach the Israelites a lesson” after they failed to lend assistance in one of his recent wars. Holofernes laid siege to the city of Bethulia, compromising its water sources. The inhabitants were in favor of yielding to the general but the leaders asked for five days, hoping that assistance would materialize.

During this waiting period the widow Judith entered Holofernes’ camp, along with her maid, under the pretext of being able to provide information that would aid his efforts. Holofernes became enamored with Judith — her intent — and prepared a sumptuous meal that, he hoped, would be a seduction vehicle. He drank too much at the dinner, however and fell asleep. Judith took the opportunity to use his sword to behead him and took his head back to the leaders of Bethulia. The shock of losing their leader in this manner eventually led to the defeat of the Assyrians.

The Paintings
Judith beheading Holofernes was Caravaggio’s first historical work. It was commissioned by Ottavia Costa, a Genoese banker. Costa was so enamored with the painting that he stipulated its inalienability in his will. It was lost to public view for several centuries until the restorer Pico Cettini reported in 1951 that he had seen it in a home. A little over 20 years later the Italian state bought the piece and exhibited it in Palazzo Barberini.

According to barberinicorsini.org, the light in the scene falls from the top left, “striking Judith’s figure in full.” Unlike the story relayed in the book of Judith, Caravaggio has Abra, Judith’s maidservant, in the room and as a wrinkled old woman. This “haggard attendant merely looks on, her eyes wide with disbelief.” Judith appears to “gracefully” recoil from her gruesome task.

Artemisia painted two versions of this story: 1611 - 1612 and 1629. As a young woman she had been raped by her teacher Agostino Tasi and, while it is believed that she was influenced by Caravaggio’s version, the cold brutality exhibited in these paintings gives a sense that she is calling on something deeper: the cold rage of the violated.

Smart History calls this “… one of the bloodiest and most vivid depictions of the scene … surpassing the version by Caravaggio … in its immediacy and striking realism.” While Judith is a shrinking violet in Caravaggio’s version — and Abra is barely there — Artemisia’s versions depict two strong young women working cooperatively to defeat an opposing force.

While the flow of blood from Caravaggio is insipid to the point of ridicule, Artemisia’s blood flow is vivid, plentiful, and explosive, flowing in multiple rivulets down the face of the mattress.

In the Gentileschi paintings the figures are directly in front of us — great for dramatic effect — and appear as though highlighted by a spotlight.

In a funny kind of way, if one can get funny about a beheading, Caravaggio’s painting is somewhat more sensitive and “feminine” in its portrayal of the scene while Gentileschi’s is much more hunter-like.

In the Footsteps of Piero della Francesca: Queen of Sheba, King Solomon, and Burial of the Wood

Just below the Death of Adam in Basilica di San Francesca's Bacci Chapel is the two-scene fresco Procession of the Queen of Sheba and M...